Permafrost
A Glimmer Among Fixed Stars
Carla Vargas discovers something moving in a field of fixed stars — and the world of astronomy changes forever.
Primordial contact with the visitor
July 1st, 2025 — Río Hurtado, Chile
Carla stood at the window, marveling at the diffuse glow of the Magellanic Clouds beginning to climb the southern sky. Warm vapors rose from her coffee mug, bringing that toasted aroma to her nostrils as the liquid warmed her hands through the ceramic contact. She expected that caffeine could help her stay awake on her last night shift before winter vacations.
Her thoughts wandered between that breathtaking sky divided in two by the vertical silhouette of the Milky Way—a splendor humans were increasingly denying themselves through reckless light pollution—and her next steps. She could finally visit her family in Maipú, Santiago, before crossing the Atlantic to visit friends in northern Spain. That would be a great trip.
Suddenly, a notification sound from the computer interrupted her thoughts. She recognized the alert. Her system only used that tone for one thing: a new object detected in the sky, previously unknown to humankind.
Excitement surged through her. She'd been working for the Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System (ATLAS) for almost a year, and she had constantly dreamed of this moment. That first instant when she would be the first human to see a new light, to observe an object never before known to humanity. Yet this eureka moment had always eluded her. While colleagues on different shifts had made significant discoveries over the past twelve months, it seemed like some cosmic joke was keeping new objects just out of her reach.
But this time felt different. She quickly opened the FITS images—the standard format for professional astronomical data—and her eyes scanned the star-populated field. She was astonished by the sheer number of visible stars. Most comets and asteroids discovered by ATLAS appeared in much less crowded regions of sky.
Surprised, she decided to investigate further. She checked the coordinates and quickly entered them into the sky database. She was immediately struck by what she saw. Asteroids typically orbit in planes close to the ecliptic—the plane in which planets orbit the Sun. This was also true for short-period comets like Halley's, which originated from the Kuiper Belt. But the image Carla was examining wasn't from a field on the ecliptic. It was a densely populated area coming, as the database confirmed, from the constellation Sagittarius.
Sagittarius was quite a famous constellation in its own right. It contained the supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way, Sagittarius A*. Just three years earlier, in 2022, it had made worldwide news when scientists revealed its image—following the path blazed by the very first black hole image captured in 2019 in a distant galaxy.
After her initial excitement, Carla realized something. The ecliptic crossed the Galactic plane near Sagittarius. This object might still be a short-period comet or an asteroid after all, she thought. But deep inside, she was hoping for a third option: a long-period comet. These objects are fascinating. They represent the most pristine members of the solar system. They are remnants of its formation, mostly untouched by solar radiation, making them our best tools for investigating our cosmic origins.
Long-period comets originate in the Oort Cloud—a spherical envelope separating our solar system from interstellar space—and they were more likely to be found in sky areas other than the ecliptic.
Carla pored anxiously through the images, one taken at 5:15 AM and another just a few minutes ago at 6:20 AM. But she couldn't detect any moving object in that overly crowded field. After a few moments, her excitement began to fade. Nothing seemed to be moving. Every point in those images, each one a star, appeared in the same place in both exposures taken just over an hour apart. This might have been another false alarm. False alarms weren't uncommon—cosmic rays striking the detector, processing artifacts, even satellites catching the light in just the wrong way.
That was how comets and asteroids were detected. Since they're relatively close to us, we can see them move against the distant, apparently fixed stars—like a tree beside the road that rapidly passes your field of view in a car while distant mountains and stars remain still. If we see a star-like object moving among those fixed stars, we know we're observing something that isn't a star. Something much closer to us.
But Carla, beginning to despair, couldn't see that moving body. She would still need to wait for her first discovery. On the bright side, her optimistic part thought, this meant she could take a deep breath and enjoy her well-deserved vacation in the northern summer.
She decided to leave the images blinking on the screen—the software rapidly alternating the two frames so the stars remained rock-still. She turned back to the window, coffee in hand, resigned to the quiet majesty of the Chilean night. Outside, the sky was a tapestry of ancient, powerful emitters; inside, her monitor was just a silent grid of data.
Then, as the frames blinked, she saw it.
She froze. A tiny, rhythmic jump.
She set the coffee down—almost missing the table—and leaned in until her nose was inches from the glass. There, right near the center of the field, a single pixel was playing a frantic game of leapfrog. In the first frame, it was nestled against a distant star; in the second, it had shifted. It was a minute, lonely glimmer—a Glühwürmchen in the middle of a city of stars—that had traversed a noticeable distance in just over an hour.
The realization hit her like a physical shock. This wasn't a false alarm. It wasn't a ghost in the sensor. It was a tiny body reflecting a few photons of stolen sunlight back to her, and her alone.
"Wait," she whispered to the empty room, her breath fogging the screen. "Wait a second... there you are."
Carla's heart began to race. She checked the photometry: magnitude 17.7 in the orange filter. Incredibly faint—about 63,000 times dimmer than the faintest star visible to the naked eye. No wonder it had been so hard to spot in that crowded field.
Finally, she'd found it! She was finally the first one observing a new light, a new body never before seen by humanity!
After several minutes confirming everything—checking the star catalog, verifying the motion, reviewing the detection parameters, examining the difference image that removed stars to leave only that barely detectable drifter—she finally did it. She pushed the button. The data moved automatically to the Minor Planet Center. Now it was in their hands to confirm the detection.
She couldn't stop refreshing the MPC webpage. The refresh button and the screen were her whole world at that moment. Every thirty seconds: reload. Nothing. Reload. Nothing. The Near-Earth Object Confirmation Page remained stubbornly unchanged. Then, after what felt like an eternity but was probably only twenty minutes, there it was: A11pl3Z. Her object. Right there in the list of unconfirmed detections, waiting for the world to verify it.
She stared at the designation. A11pl3Z—the MPC's temporary designation, built from the discovery date and order. What an ugly name for such a momentous discovery, she thought. However, she knew that it would eventually get a more prosaic name after its orbit was categorized by the MPC. She allowed herself a brief smile at the vanity: Comet Vargas—her mother's favorite author shared her surname. But she quickly pushed the thought aside.
At that moment, she wanted to call everyone: her mother, her friends, her former professors, her supervisor. She would have done it right now, in the middle of the night. This could be the greatest moment of her life. But she had to be careful. The MPC still needed to confirm it. It might be an error, perhaps a known comet misidentified due to the crowded field. She had to remain cautious.
She decided to simply email Dr. Morales, her supervisor, to inform him of the tentative discovery. She kept it brief and professional: "Detected possible new object at RA 18:07:27.68, Dec -18:41:40.2. Submitted to MPC as A11pl3Z. Appears to be moving but in very crowded field. Recommend follow-up if confirmed."
She hit "send" and leaned back in her chair. It was 2:30 in the morning, local time, and A11pl3Z was somewhere in Sagittarius, right above her head, at the zenith of that beautiful sky, invisible to the naked eye. Her coffee sat cold and half-full on the table. But Carla didn't need it anymore. This discovery had enough power to keep her awake without mundane caffeine.
Universal Time was 6:30—already morning in Europe. Soon, observatories worldwide would wake up, check the MPC's Near-Earth Object Confirmation Page, and see A11pl3Z's coordinates. What would happen next was one of astronomy's most remarkable traditions: a global collaboration would begin.
Determining a comet's orbit requires more than just two observations. Orbits aren't straight lines—they are curves, specifically conic sections like ellipses and circles. To calculate the true path of a comet around the Sun, astronomers need multiple observations spread across time, creating what they call an "observational arc." The longer the arc, the more accurate the orbital solution. The same way two points can draw a line, dozens of points across days or weeks reveal the precise elliptical orbit of an astronomical object. Or in extremely rare cases, something else entirely.
Her email alert chimed. Six hours had passed since the discovery. The message was from the Zwicky Transient Facility in California—they'd found A11pl3Z in their archive! Two observations from June 28th and 29th. The observational arc now extended back three more days.
Carla felt a surge of validation. It was real! ZTF had independently captured it.
She finished her shift as dawn broke over Río Hurtado, but before heading home, she couldn't resist. She opened her own ATLAS archives and started searching those crowded Sagittarius fields from late June. And there it was again! Frame after frame, that faint wanderer drifting slowly against the background stars. She'd been photographing it for days without realizing.
She submitted her new findings to the MPC and drove home, exhausted but unable to sleep. Instead, she opened her laptop and sent an email to the airline: vacation postponed. She wanted to be present for the follow-up round!
In the end, science was a peculiar career. It was full of hard work and countless frustrations—experiments that didn't work, funding deadlines, postdoc positions, papers rejected or sent back demanding major revisions. But all of those hurdles, all those difficult moments, evaporated like the dust and gas sublimating from that small reddish object she'd just discovered. Science was a life of method, a life of careful tests and patient work, leading—in most cases—to a single ephemeral moment of joy, if any at all.
But the feeling of being the first human to see a new object, to witness something never before known to exist—that joy was beyond words. For this, vacations could wait. Carla was living her career-defining moment.
July 2nd, 2025
Carla woke to dozens of emails. The ATLAS team had found more pre-discovery observations going back to June 25th. Then another message arrived: ZTF had found even earlier detections—all the way back to June 14th. The observational arc now spanned eighteen days!
News could not stop for a second. At lunchtime, Las Cumbres Observatory's network confirmed that it was tracking it. The 2-meter Faulkes Telescopes were obtaining measurements. Then came the message from the Kottamia Astronomical Observatory in Egypt: "We have A11pl3Z. Confirmed motion. Appears to show slight coma."
A coma!
That diffuse cloud of gas and dust that surrounds a comet's nucleus as it warms and begins to vaporize. Not the tail that most people picture, but the envelope itself, the atmosphere of the comet. It was the defining feature that separated comets from asteroids. This wasn't a rocky body. It was an icy one, already becoming active.
Then Palomar. Apache Point. Telescopes from Hawaii to South Africa to Tenerife were all turning toward Sagittarius, each sending their astrometric measurements to the Minor Planet Center. Professional observatories and amateur astronomers alike, telescopes ranging from 20 centimeters to 3 meters, all contributing data points to refine the orbit.
Carla watched JPL HORIZONS throughout the day as the orbital solution updated with each new batch of observations. The computers were fitting all those positions—dozens, then hundreds of measurements—into the mathematical parameters that defined the object's path through the Solar System.
By July 3rd, something unusual was becoming clear. The orbit wasn't settling into the typical elliptical shape expected for a comet. The eccentricity—the measure of how elongated an orbit is—kept climbing with each refinement.
July 6th, 2025
Five days after discovery, the orbital solution had stabilized. Observations from 97 facilities worldwide—from June 14th through July 4th—had been fed into JPL's orbit determination software. The European Southern Observatory's Very Large Telescope had even provided ultra-high-precision measurements during excellent sky conditions.
Carla opened JPL HORIZONS and scrolled to the orbital elements:
Eccentricity: e = 6.27
Trajectory: Hyperbolic (unbound)
Classification: Interstellar
She stared at the screen, her hands suddenly cold despite the warm office.
Ellipses—the normal bound orbits of comets and planets—had eccentricities less than 1. A circle was 0. An elongated ellipse approached but never reached 1. But a value greater than 1 meant something fundamentally different. Picture yourself with an elastic band. You stretch it to the maximum. As long as it doesn't break, it remains an ellipse with an eccentricity approaching one. But then, suddenly, it breaks. The eccentricity becomes larger than 1. That's no longer an ellipse, but a hyperbola. An open curve. An unbound trajectory.
Even the most extreme comets we knew, those that dived from the deepest reaches of the Oort Cloud, clung to the Sun with eccentricities of 0.999. They were stretched, yes, but they were still tethered. But 6.27? That wasn't a stretch. That was a clean break. That was an object with so much kinetic energy that the Sun's massive gravity was nothing more than a minor annoyance it would breeze past on its way back to the stars.
Not just interstellar—but racing through our solar system with such tremendous velocity that nothing could capture it. Not just passing through, but blazing through. This was nearly twice as unbound as 2I/Borisov, the previous interstellar comet discovered in 2019. The most dramatically hyperbolic trajectory yet observed.
This wasn't an asteroid or a comet from the Kuiper Belt. It wasn't from the Oort Cloud. It wasn't any of the options she'd considered that first night.
It was a fourth option: interstellar. A temporal visitor. A messenger from deep time, here for just months, then gone forever.
The official announcement had already arrived from the Minor Planet Center:
"The Minor Planet Center announces the discovery of 3I/ATLAS (C/2025 N1), the third confirmed interstellar object. Discovered by the ATLAS survey at Río Hurtado, Chile on 2025 July 1..."
3I/ATLAS. Not A11pl3Z. Not Comet Vargas.
3I—the third interstellar object.
ATLAS—for the survey that found it.
Only twice before in all of human history had we detected visitors from beyond our solar system. 1I/'Oumuamua in 2017—strange, elongated, showing no cometary activity. 2I/Borisov in 2019—a comet, yes, but one that behaved almost normally, like our own Oort Cloud comets.
And now 3I/ATLAS. Hers. The Vargas comet.
The preliminary orbit showed it was 4.47 astronomical units from the Sun—just inside Jupiter's orbit—and 3.5 AU from Earth, three and a half times farther than our own Sun. A tiny, dim object in the outer solar system, barely reflecting enough sunlight for even a professional telescope to detect.
Carla stood at her window again that evening, looking toward the mountains. Somewhere out there, beyond those peaks, beyond the atmosphere, beyond Mars, an ancient traveler was racing through our solar system at 60 kilometers per second. It had been falling toward the Sun for thousands of years, would swing past it in October, and then leave forever into the darkness between stars.
She thought about all those observatories that had contributed—the teams in Hawaii mining archives, the astronomers in Egypt confirming the coma, the network spanning continents. The tenacious and diligent amateur astronomers with their backyard equipment. She'd been the first to see it, but it had taken a global community to understand what it was.
And there was something else that made astronomy unique: the laboratory itself was shared human patrimony. The sky belonged to everyone—scientists, amateurs, and the curious public alike. Anyone with a telescope could observe and measure, confirming what professionals saw, contributing their own discoveries. In what other field could a backyard enthusiast with modest equipment participate in the same research as a PhD with access to world-class observatories? The cosmos was democracy in action.
That was how science worked. Not lone discoveries, but collaboration. Data shared freely, measurements combined, understanding built together.
She opened her laptop and finally wrote to her mother, tears of joy blurring her vision: "Mamá, I found something. We found something. I need to tell you about it."
That night, unable to sleep, Carla returned to her window and looked toward Sagittarius. 3I/ATLAS was out there, 4.47 AU away, an ancient wanderer racing through our solar system at speeds that would carry it back to the stars. It had been falling toward the Sun for thousands of years, perhaps tens of thousands, pulled by gravity across the vast emptiness between stellar systems. It would swing past perihelion in October, closer to the Sun than it had been in billions of years, and then leave forever into the darkness.
She'd been the first human to see it. But it had been traveling for billions of years to reach this moment—to be discovered, measured, understood. What secrets did it carry in its frozen heart? What could it tell us about worlds that died before our Sun was born? Why was it already active so far from the Sun? What was releasing that coma at distances where comets should remain dormant?
3I/ATLAS wasn't just a discovery. It was a messenger. And its message was still being decoded.
To understand what she'd found, we must go back to the beginning—not the beginning of its journey through our solar system, but the beginning of its very existence.